Average Cost of New Siding

Siding replacements are for the bold. If you want to truly change the look of your home’s exterior, this is the exterior upgrade to choose. As it is one of the single biggest home renovations, it can also be one of the biggest investments. More than anything the average cost of new siding for your home is determined by the material you choose – and that’s what we’re digging into today.

At Choice Home Remodeling, we’re the home improvement company that handles it all, from your gorgeous new kitchen to the siding that transforms your home. In today’s blog, we’re breaking down the average cost to replace your siding with the most popular materials on the market, while giving you the pros and cons of each. Keep in mind, though – these numbers are estimates based on the average home, so to find out what your siding installation will cost, contact us for a FREE estimate.

Cost to Install Different Siding Materials

The most popular siding materials in Lancaster, PA are vinyl siding, fiber cement, and composite siding. When installed by an expert contractor, all three can provide you decades of reliable performance and gorgeous curb appeal. Let’s explore the different materials and the average cost to install them:

Premium Vinyl Siding
Green vinyl siding with burnt red shutters

There is a big difference between the heaviest gauge luxury siding we install from brands like Provia, Mastic, and CertainTeed and the lesser-quality builder grade vinyl. Vinyl is a practical and budget-friendly option and is the most common siding material all across the country.

Pros:

Vinyl is the Least Expensive Material
Comes in a Wider Variety of Colors than Ever
25 to 30 Year Fade Warranty on Dark Colors
Lifetime warranty on the product
Easy to Clean
Longest lasting siding

Cons:

Has the Vinyl Look Which Some Homeowners Don’t Like
Can Be Cut, Chipped or Damaged

The most cost-effective siding option

Fiber Cement

Fiber cement is a luxury siding material with a distinct wood look. A popular option to upgrade both vinyl siding and to replace wood siding, this material does come at a higher price point than vinyl. James Hardie is the big name brand behind this luxury siding material that you may have heard of.

Pros:

Stands Out Compared to Vinyl
Beautiful and Bright Color Options
Has a 15-Year Warranty on Paint
Can Replicate the Look of Wood Siding

Cons:

Needs to Be Repainted Periodically
Can Deteriorate If Paint Isn’t Maintained
Can Crack and Break

Can be as much as twice the price of vinyl siding

Everlast Composite Siding

This siding option is crafted from a combination of real wood and vinyl materials. One of our most highly-recommended products, Everlast Composite siding has a distinct look but also boasts convenient practical benefits.

Pros:

Finish Extends the Whole Way through the Material for Maximum Color and Strength
Composite Siding Has a Lifetime Warranty
Replicates Wood Much Like Fiber Cement
Impervious to the Elements

Cons:

Most Expensive Siding Material to Install

Can be as much as twice the price of vinyl siding

See some of our favorite Mastic, Certainteed and James Hardie colors.

Get Your Free Siding Installation Quote

Now you have a pretty good idea of the average cost of new siding. However, these are only estimates – your price for new siding may be higher or lower.

The best way to find out your cost to install new siding? Schedule a 100% free in-home consultation with the Choice Home Remodeling team. Our exterior designers will help you find the right style for your home, chose the right material for your needs, and give you a free quote!

Share This:

Client Reviews

Write a review » See all reviews »

Excellent

Choice Windows, Doors & More, Inc.

Work so clean you can barely even tell they were there. They stand by their work and are professional through and through. Best part about my project is that they customized my new front door and reused my door slab at my request. Fits like it was made for the house. Excellent work Gents!!!!

Response from the owner:Alan, thank you for the five star review! We are thrilled with how this customized door installation turned out and that we were able to help you bring a unique entryway to your Ephrata neighborhood.

Replaced front door with double doors and rear patio doors with double doors. Choice Home Remodeling was our contractor to do the work. Had 2 door specialists working for 3 days. I call them specialists due to their years of experience and the pride they took in making sure everything was right. Plan on having more work done by them and highly recommend their services.

Response from the owner:Thanks so much, John! We really enjoyed working with you on door replacements in Lititz, PA. The 8' front door creates a beautiful entryway. Our team takes a lot of pride in their work, so it means a lot to hear that their experience and attention to detail stood out. We appreciate the recommendation and look forward to helping with your next home improvement project!

Tim and the team at Choice did an excellent job on our new front door. The Choice showroom is very nice and Tim led us through the buying process very professionally and with no pressure. The door arrived ahead of schedule and Jeff did an outstanding job in installation. No dust or mess and the door looks awesome! Highly recommended!!

Response from the owner:Thank you Robert for the review! We are proud to have provided you with a positive experience from your time in the showroom through installation. Please let us know if we can be of service to you for your future home remodeling needs.

We love Choice Home Remodeling - over the years Choice has replaced our front door, multiple windows, renovated our Kitchen and replaced our garage doors! Pricing is fair and the work done by Choice is Excellent. Highly Recommend Choice for home remodeling. Will be replacing more windows and sliding door in 2026, so the first call will be to Pete Steiner at Choice!

Response from the owner:Thank you Rob for your review and continued trust in Choice. It is a pleasure to be your go to company for your Home Remodeling needs. Pete and all of us here at Choice look forward to working with you again this year!